
On recharter eve, Dave submits a model framework to make OA tribal-agreement compliance verifiable, auditable, and consequential.
To: The National Order of the Arrow Committee and Professional Staff
Date: December 31, 2025
To the National Order of the Arrow Committee and Professional Staff,
This submission is intentionally timed.
On the eve of the annual recharter deadline, the National Order of the Arrow has required local lodges to attest that they maintain current agreements with appropriate tribal authorities governing American Indian Activities. This requirement is substantively correct and long supported by OA policy language. It acknowledges, at least in principle, that cultural representation without consent is not honor but appropriation.
What remains unresolved is whether this requirement is being administered as a compliance obligation or merely received as an assertion.
A compliance regime requires more than attestation. It requires verification, documentation, traceability, and consequence. Absent those elements, neither members, councils, tribal partners, nor the public can reasonably distinguish between meaningful enforcement and symbolic process.
To date, the National Office has not published aggregate compliance results, articulated a verification methodology, nor described how non-compliance is identified, corrected, or sanctioned. In that vacuum, it is impossible to assess whether the requirement is functioning as policy or as representation.
The attached framework is offered as a concrete, operational model of what compliance would look like if the intent of the requirement were fully realized.
It does not propose new standards.
It does not reinterpret OA policy.
It simply renders existing expectations auditable.
Specifically, it provides:
- A clear enumeration of existing OA recharter requirements related to American Indian Activities, grounded in OA publications and guidance
- A compliance matrix suitable for review, correction, and governance oversight
- A lodge-level checklist that eliminates ambiguity about what “compliance” means in practice
- A reporting template capable of demonstrating compliance status without disclosing sensitive agreements
This is not an adversarial submission. It is a governance document.
If the National Office already maintains internal controls that meet or exceed this standard, publication of aggregate compliance data—without lodge-level attribution if preferred—would immediately and decisively resolve the concerns this framework addresses. If such controls do not exist, the absence itself represents a material governance gap, particularly given the historical and cultural context in which these activities occur.
In matters involving Indigenous communities and longstanding patterns of harm, good faith is not a substitute for due diligence. Intent does not mitigate impact, and aspiration does not replace accountability.
The Order of the Arrow frequently invokes concepts of honor, obligation, and example. Those concepts acquire institutional meaning only when paired with systems that verify behavior rather than presume it.
This framework is therefore submitted not as criticism, but as a practical illustration of what responsible stewardship requires at this moment.
Respectfully submitted,
Dave McGrath
(original signed)
Attachments:
Google Drive Shared Folder: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1GsXbXhes-D-LTGRj4fnutmytI8rMsyV8?usp=sharing
- Executive Summary.pdf
- Attachment A Enumerated Recharter Requirements.pdf
- Attachment B Compliance Matrix – Audit Model.pdf
- Attachment C OA Lodge Annual Recharter Checklist.pdf
- Attachment D Public Transparency – Reporting Requirements.pdf
- Email – Model Compliance and Verification Framework.pdf
Originally posted by Dave McGrath in ‘Scouters – Not Afraid of Controversy’ on December 31, 2025; Facebook post ID 3080440072141383. Republished verbatim; lead image is a generated mobile-style post card. Attachments are listed in the letter text; the Google Drive folder link is preserved in the body.