Independent Office of BSA Accountability

Keep it safe, don't keep it secret.

OPEN LETTER: A Public Accountability Challenge to the National Order of the Arrow

Dave’s December repost of his open letter again demands the National OA publish its 2026 recharter tribal-agreement compliance counts, not assurances.

Generated mobile-style card showing Dave McGrath's December 27, 2025 open letter title and opening text.
Generated mobile-style card for Dave McGrath’s December 27, 2025 open letter, showing its title and opening text. Images in this post are evidence retained under our historical images policy.

Date: January 1, 2026

To:
The National Committee and National Officers of the Order of the Arrow
c/o Scouting America

Subject: Publish the 2026 Lodge Recharter Compliance Data for Tribal Agreements

This letter is written as a matter of public record and public accountability.

Effective January 1, 2026, the National Order of the Arrow implemented a binding policy change requiring that any OA lodge engaging in American Indian–related programming—including but not limited to ceremonies, regalia, dancing, drumming, crafts, and pow-wows—must have a bona fide, documented agreement with a state- or federally recognized tribal authority authorizing such activities.¹

This policy was not aspirational.
It was not optional.
And it was explicitly tied to the 2026 lodge recharter process.²

What this necessarily means

As part of annual recharter, OA lodges were required to affirmatively attest whether such an agreement existed. While the policy specifies that the underlying documentation is retained at the council level, the attestation of compliance is national-facing and is a condition of recharter.³

Accordingly, the National Order of the Arrow already possesses—as of December 31, 2025—an aggregate dataset indicating:

  • how many lodges attested to having qualifying tribal agreements, and
  • how many did not.

This is not a matter of speculation. It is a direct and unavoidable consequence of your own recharter framework.

The problem

Despite this, the National Order of the Arrow has:

  • published no aggregate compliance numbers,
  • released no percentages or counts,
  • articulated no verification or audit mechanism,
  • disclosed no enforcement or remediation process, and
  • announced no plan or timeline for transparency.

The absence of accountability is not incidental. It is structural.

By design:

  • documentation is siloed locally,
  • compliance is asserted rather than demonstrated,
  • national leadership has visibility without responsibility, and
  • tribes, members, councils, and the public are left unable to verify whether reform is real or merely claimed.

Why this matters

The Order of the Arrow has long described itself as “Scouting’s National Honor Society.”
Honor, however, is not ceremonial language. It is a practice.

At a minimum, honor requires:

  • transparency,
  • verifiability, and
  • accountability for stated commitments—especially when those commitments concern Indigenous sovereignty and the use of Indigenous cultural expressions.

A system that relies solely on self-attestation, with no public accounting, does not meet that standard. It substitutes institutional trust-me language for demonstrable responsibility.

This is a direct challenge

Accordingly, we formally call on the National Order of the Arrow to publish, without delay:

  1. The total number of OA lodges chartered for 2026;
  2. The number and percentage of lodges that attested to having qualifying tribal agreements as required by policy;
  3. The number of lodges that did not; and
  4. A clear description of any enforcement, remediation, or cessation of programming required for noncompliant lodges.

No lodge-level or tribe-specific details are required.
Only aggregate accountability.

Silence is a choice

If the agreements are real, the numbers can be published.
If the reform is substantive, the data will support it.
If the Order of the Arrow stands for honor, transparency should not be feared.

Absent disclosure, the unavoidable conclusion is that the system was designed to avoid accountability while preserving appearances—a pattern that has historically characterized the OA’s relationship with American Indian imagery and authority.

Silence, in this context, is not neutrality.
It is an answer.

We invite the National Order of the Arrow to respond with data, not assurances.

Respectfully submitted,

Concerned Scouters, alumni, and members of the public


Footnotes

1. Order of the Arrow, American Indian Activities Policy, establishing January 1, 2026 as the effective date for requiring written agreements with state- or federally recognized tribes for American Indian programming.

2. Order of the Arrow, 2026 Lodge Charter Renewal Materials, incorporating compliance attestation into the annual recharter process.

3. Order of the Arrow guidance specifying that councils retain agreements while lodges attest to compliance during recharter; national office does not centrally store agreements but necessarily receives compliance affirmations.


Endnote

This image exists because the current policy framework was designed to avoid accountability. That’s dodgy.

The National Order of the Arrow could have required that every lodge claiming a bona fide license or agreement from a tribal authority submit that documentation to a central, inspectable, public-facing repository—with appropriate redactions where necessary. That would have created transparency, trust, and verifiable compliance.

You did not do that.

Instead, the system relies on self-attestation, fragmented local record-keeping, and the absence of any published aggregate data. National visibility without public accountability is not an accident; it is a choice.

If this reform is serious, fix it now.
Publish the counts.
Create a transparent verification mechanism.
Close the accountability gap before others document it for you.

Honor is not asserted.
It is demonstrated.

Originally posted by Dave McGrath in ‘Scouters – Not Afraid of Controversy’ on December 27, 2025; Facebook post ID 3077300485788675. Republished verbatim; lead image is a generated mobile-style post card. This is the December 27, 2025 posting of the same open letter also archived as the January 1, 2026 posting.