The Archive is the Office of BSA Accountability’s record of what was said.
Scouting arguments live and die in comment threads, in groups that change their names, in posts that are edited, deleted, or taken down after a suspension, and in screenshots that circulate without a date, a source, or a context. When the record disappears, the argument becomes a rumor. When the record is kept, with its date, its author, and its context intact, the argument can be checked.
That is what this archive is for. It keeps what was said, so it can be checked later, by anyone, including by people who disagree with the Office.
What the Archive is
- A preservation record, not a celebration. Items are kept because they were said, and because they matter to the Office’s accountability work, not because the Office agrees with them.
- A provenance record. Each item carries, where it can be recovered: who said it, where it was said, when it was said, and what it was in reply to, as far as the public record allows.
- A version record. When an item is corrected, amended, or followed up, the correction is added as a dated amendment. The earlier version is not silently rewritten. That is the same rule the Office uses on the accountability site: corrections as dated amendments, never silent edits.
- An evidence record. The archive exists so that claims about the past — who said what, when a group changed its name, when a post was removed, when a policy was announced — can be tested against something other than memory.
What the Archive is not
- Not an endorsement. An item being archived does not mean the Office agrees with it, approves of it, or recommends it. Some items are archived precisely because the Office disagrees with them, and because the disagreement needs a record to stand on.
- Not a hall of fame, and not a wall of shame. It is a record, kept plainly, so readers can judge for themselves.
- Not a substitute for the accountability site. The accountability site, accountability.scoutingoutsidethelines.org, is where the Office argues, investigates, and publishes its own work. The Archive is where the underlying record is kept, so those arguments can be checked.
- Not a complete record of everything ever said about Scouting. It is a curated record, built as time and evidence allow, with gaps stated plainly where they exist.
What is in the Archive now
- Save the OA Archive — 31 published posts, Dave McGrath’s own posts from the Save the OA group, backdated, comments closed, with provenance and policy lines.
- Let’s Not Save the OA Archive — 29 published posts, Dave McGrath’s own posts from his own group. This collection is a category, not a separate page; its explanation sits on the Index page under its heading.
- Total published: 60 posts.
The 13 items held under holds 1 and 2 were published October 25, 2026, with the provenance limits stated on each item.
The Index
The Archive is not just a chronological pile. Its Index, linked from the navigation above, is the way in, in three sections:
By date — by original post date, newest first, with a year and month breakdown. This is the timeline: it shows what was said when, in the order it was said, so a reader can follow a controversy as it unfolded.
By collection — Save the OA Archive, then Let’s Not Save the OA Archive, newest first within each.
By topic — by subject, not by date or author. Topics include tribal agreements and attestation, lodge names and totems, warbonnets and regalia, powwows and hosting, OA ceremonies and inductions, Scout Law and honor, Pride and inclusion, group administration and deleted posts, and correspondence with OA and BSA leadership.
A post can appear under more than one topic.
An index entry is not a summary and not a verdict; it is a pointer to the full item, with its date and provenance line.
Index link: https://archive.scoutingoutsidethelines.org/index/
What is withheld, and why
Read this before assuming the Archive is complete. The Controversy track below is not published yet, and it will not be published until it receives its own separate approval and verification pass. The Save the OA essay posts below are not missing; they are published as essay pages on the accountability site and are therefore not duplicated here.
- Controversy archive track — about 764 posts, flooring at May 12, 2016, with a planned record back to about 2014. Withheld because it was never covered by the earlier blanket approval. This track is larger, older, and harder to verify than Save the OA and Let’s Not Save the OA, and it needs a separate editorial rule and verification pass before publication, in stages, with gaps and conflicts flagged, not smoothed over.
- Save the OA posts already published as essays — 9 posts. These are not missing from the record. They are published as essay pages on the accountability site, with the original Facebook post footnoted, and they are therefore not duplicated in the Archive, by design, to avoid two versions drifting apart.
How items are treated — provenance, images, and historical images
Every published post carries a provenance line: where it came from, when it was captured, and what was changed, if anything, in preparing it for the archive.
Every content image carries two parts: alt text, concise and descriptive only, for accessibility, and a visible caption, a curatorial statement saying what the image documents, its evidentiary role, and the policy context where relevant.
Images in the Archive are evidence retained under the Office’s historical images policy. That policy is stated on the accountability site’s About page, at about/#note-historical-images: images are shown as evidence, never as endorsement; they are documented because the Office holds that the practices they show should end, including under the OA’s January 1, 2026 American Indian Activities policy; they are presented plainly as a record of what was done, not as a celebration.
Captions in archive posts end with that historical-images reference, linked to the accountability site’s About note, exactly as on the accountability site. One reference per caption, as the closing sentence.
Where a caption is the author’s own statement, it is presented as the author’s statement, not as a verified fact.
Where a date or a year is inferred, it is flagged as inferred.
Where two sources conflict — for example, on a date — the conflict is flagged, not resolved by picking the tidier one.
What we record, and what we don’t
When the Archive goes live, we will not keep a public log of the frame. Templates, CSS, masthead, footer, navigation, fonts, link colors, list presentation, and wording on the primary pages themselves will not be changelogged; the current version will be the current version. Until then, the site is visible, not live, and no formal log is kept.
When the Archive goes live, we will keep an open record on each imported article: where it came from, its original post ID and date, what text and images were imported, and any change after import as a dated amendment appended to that post, never a silent edit. If a change is not worth writing down as an amendment, it will not be made to an imported article. That is where the transparency will live: on the provenance of the essays and evidence we bring in, not on every layout tweak.
How to use the Archive
- To check a claim. If someone says “that was never said,” or “that was said differently,” look here first, and check the date and the provenance line.
- To follow a thread. Items are grouped by their original group and by their original conversation, so a reply can be read in context, not as a screenshot floating free.
- To see change over time. Group renames, post removals, policy announcements, and suspensions leave a trace here, in date order, so a timeline can be built from the record, not from recollection.
- To correct the record. If an item is wrong, incomplete, or misattributed, tell the Office at office@accountability.scoutingoutsidethelines.org. Corrections will be published as dated amendments, with the error, the fix, and the reason named, and the earlier version preserved in the record.
- To cite the Archive. Cite the item, its date, and its provenance line, not just the Archive as a whole. A citation that cannot be traced to a specific item, on a specific date, is not a citation from this Archive.
Why keep what was said, even when it is uncomfortable?
Because accountability without a record is just a debate about memory, and memory loses to whoever shouts loudest or deletes fastest. A record that is kept, dated, and open to correction does three things that memory cannot do:
- It protects the people who were quoted, by showing what they actually said, in context, instead of a paraphrase that drifts.
- It protects the people who are arguing now, by giving them something checkable to stand on, instead of a screenshot that may have been cropped.
- It protects the future reader, who was not in the room, by leaving a trail they can follow back to the source.
That is the Archive’s value. Not that it settles every argument, but that it makes every argument checkable.
Who runs the Archive, and who decides what goes in
The Archive is run by the Independent Office of BSA Accountability. Dave McGrath is its curator. His own posts are published under his standing pre-approval, and he reviews them on the live site afterward. Other people’s posts are reserved for his review and are never auto-uploaded.